Criminalising hate speech is an issue with with far reaching consequences for every South African. Speaking to the topic are Advocate Mark Oppenheimer, Professor Anton Harber and Cynthia Stimpel who discuss the topic with reference to the Constitution and the Hate Speech Bill, the potential effect of the Bill on the media, and impact it may have on whistleblowers respectively.
Media
The Prevention and Combating of Hate Crimes and Hate Speech Bill would criminalise racist speech. Almost every supporter of the bill see legislation as a means to “eliminate racism”. The problem is that trying to eliminate racism is like trying to pin down mercury. Racism is an expression of people’s thoughts and feelings, upbringing and experience, interactions and education — these all change over time. Often racism ebbs and flows depending on people’s personal experiences of the political forces in society. Criminalisation isn't the answer.
‘To tamper with the author’s words because of the sensibilities of present-day readers is unacceptable. The minute you do this Huckleberry Finn stops being the book that Twain wrote' - Peter Messent of the University of Nottingham. The same applies to any modern day author whose words are tampered with by sensitivity readers.
Kenny Kunene of the Patriotic Alliance called Julius Malema a 'cockroach', a 'little frog', and a 'criminal'. A judge found Kunene guilty of hate speech. I think the judge was wrong.
In an interview on Spectator TV author Lionel Shriver talks about the war on words by academia. She describes it in an article as 'the linguistic pigeon shooting'.
Toby Young, General Secretary of the Free Speech Union UK was joined by Sara Gon, Director of the FSU South Africa and Jonathan Ayling, Chief Executive of the FSU New Zealand to discuss a wide range of topics including how free speech is curtailed in the media, the importance of hearing contrary opinions and the commonalities experienced by our respective organisations.
Panel discussion about the failed diversity intervention at Fish Hoek High
The woke insist that 'I don't see colour' or 'I am colourblind' are actually expressions of racism in that you ignore a fundamental feature of a person. We don't agree. We believe they are positive terms that merely reflect that a person's colour is not the basis upon which a person is judged.